Description of Dr. Werner in the chapter Princess Mary. Composition on the topic: Pechorin and Dr. Werner, a comparative description of the heroes of the novel by M. Yu

The protagonist of the work, Grigory Pechorin, while on vacation in the Caucasus, meets Dr. Werner, who is a minor character in the novel, on the waters.

Men are very different from each other not only in appearance, but also in character traits, but they have a large number of similar qualities among themselves.

Pechorin and Werner are people of the same origin, revolving in the same circle and being experts in secular society, who love to philosophize and talk on abstract topics.

Both received an excellent education, have logical thinking, observation, a sharp mind and an evil tongue.

The characteristic features of the heroes are an independent disposition, pride, based on their own principles, personal opinion, sometimes expressed in skeptical and cynical views. At the same time, men have insight and the ability for subtle psychology that studies the secrets of the human soul.

The doctor and Gregory are endowed with exquisite taste, they are genuinely attracted to women, but they never entered into marriage. To each other, the characters feel mutual trust and interest.

However, despite the similarities between men, there are fundamental differences between them.

By age and position, Pechorin is a young rich man, while the doctor is much older than Grigory and belongs to the circle of impoverished intellectuals. Outwardly, Pechorin is very attractive, and Werner cannot boast of a beautiful appearance.

Werner, being a doctor by profession, by virtue of his activities, strives to save the patient's life, and Pechorin, being a military officer, aims to take the life of others, even from the enemy.

Having psychological knowledge, the doctor never puts them into practice, while Pechorin constantly and with great activity uses this talent to satisfy his ambitions and whims.

Dr. Werner is laconic, not subject to the desire to pour out emotional experiences to anyone, Grigory, on the contrary, feels the need to reveal his secrets and thoughts and chooses Werner as a vest in which to cry

Werner loves the female sex with a fierce passion, comparing women to a magical forest, he is capable of long romances, deep love and compassion. Pechorin, on the other hand, treats women consumeristically, believing that it is unacceptable to become a slave to his beloved girl, he tries to bypass women who have a strong will and a strong character.

Composition by Pechorin and Dr. Werner

In the chapter “Princess Mary”, Pechorin meets the doctor and their communication allows Lermontov to reveal the character traits of his hero.

The protagonist of the work and Werner are people of the same social stratum, but who have chosen different occupations. They became friends with the desire inherent in both to destroy their lives. Pechorin was exiled to the Caucasus for misconduct. Werner lost his practice due to bullying and ridicule of patients.

The chapter pays great attention to Pechorin's relationship with the princess and his view of women. The officer looks at them like they are toys.

Werner is introduced into the novel to demonstrate another more noble type of behavior. He is ready to sacrifice a lot for the sake of love, seeks to conquer the fair sex. Easy victories are enough for Pechorin, and not so much for possessing a woman, but for the sake of "winning on points." He falls in love with Princess Mary simply out of sporting interest, not even considering it necessary to explain himself after her declaration of love for him.

The attitude towards friendship between Pechorin and Werner is also different. The “superfluous person” does not really need it, as it burdens, imposing obligations. In addition, the events described in the work take place in the nineteenth century, a time more filled with romance and stormy, flaunted expressions of feelings. Werner takes this calmly, like most of his contemporaries, Pechorin, although he got along with him, this is clearly burdensome. He does not just need openness and sacrifice, so he is soon discarded.

Both heroes have a certain attraction to death, they are not afraid of it. However, Pechorin, by and large, strives for it. The officer commits risky acts, tempts fate, while Dr. Werner calmly waits for her onset. He sees no meaning in his life. Before the duel with Grushnitsky, Pechorin is overwhelmed by thoughts about the meaning of his existence. Knowing that his pistol will not be loaded and that his opponent can easily kill him, he makes no attempt to avoid the duel.

During the duel, Pechorin demonstrates his courage and nobility. Having let the enemy shoot first, he invites him to end the matter amicably. Pechorin shows not only his fatalism and craving for death, not only nobility, without which the nobles would have to drag out a miserable existence, but also the absence of cruelty and thirst to destroy. He does not feel any particular craving to stay in this world, but he does not want to take someone else's life either. Werner knows that the gun of the main character of the novel is not loaded, but does not voice this fact at the duel, in fact, committing a betrayal. His image serves in the novel in order to shade the feelings and experiences of an outstanding person.

Werner is a character in Lermontov's story "A Hero of Our Time". He meets in the chapter "Princess Mary", and serves as a doctor and friend of Pechorin. Werner, just like Pechorin, is a deep skeptic, a materialist, an egoist, and a person who has learned all the necessary “keys to the heart”. He does not particularly sympathize with his time and the people it gives rise to, although he is not cold towards them, but on the contrary, he vividly feels the spiritual beauty in people, which, without a doubt, is present in him.

He is short and thin, somewhat physically similar to a child. One leg is longer than the other - and the head is huge compared to the body. This is one of the few differences between him and Pechorin. Compared to him, Werner is ugly. Possessing kindness, he faithfully wears the nickname “Mephistopheles”, for which he thanks his keen eye and evil tongue, with which he penetrates into the essence of a person that he keeps behind his “mask”.

Pechorin thinks that his friend is endowed with the gift of foresight. Having no idea about the future, Werner says that in the future Grushnitsky will fall at the hands of Pechorin. Otherwise, the dialogues of the two friends look like two opponents worthy of each other are fighting in a verbal duel. Another difference between the two friends is that Werner is unwilling to change. His passion is to live in the rhythm familiar to life, without changing it. Werner warns Pechorin about Grushnitsky's conspiracy and about a possible murder (indeed, during a duel, bullets will not be put into Pechorin's pistol on purpose), although he is afraid of extra responsibility for someone. After the murder of Grushnitsky by Pechorin, he steps aside, wanting to have nothing to do with this act. Pechorin, in turn, recognizes such actions in Werner as cowardice and weakness, believing that the personal well-being for the doctor is much more important than their friendship.

Werner is similar due to his skepticism to Pechorin, but his human sincerity (Werner cried over a dying soldier) is more similar to Maxim Maksimych. There are many disagreements in this image, and any poet will find in it combinations of both strong vital qualities and weak ones. However, comparing Pechorin and Werner, the second is a more holistic personality, viable, able to find pluses in people.

Option 2

Werner is a military medic. After all, as you know, there should be a lot in common between friends, and Pechorin is a good friend of the hero.

“He is a skeptic and a materialist, like almost all doctors ...”, this is how the author describes Werner. And this is exactly what he is similar to the main character. You can even say that he is not averse to laughing at people. Also, the secondary hero of the work does not have great wealth and has always dreamed of them. As it later became clear that he did not want to do anything for his dream.

Werner also thinks about women that their mind is very stupid and impossible to understand. For him, they are complex and incomprehensible in their actions. But at the same time, Pechorin's friend is attentive to women and will achieve his goal, although he outwardly is not very handsome. As it soon became known that he despises the society in which noble people. Considering them worthless and useless people. But at the same time he is kind, because he would not cry over a soldier.

About his appearance, they say that he was not particularly pleasant. But he has clothes that are quite fashionable and always neat. He also has intelligent thoughts, because it was Pechorin who decided that he was a good conversationalist. The poet also lives in him, it is his inner world that has such features. He does not want to get married, because he believes that he is not ready and will not be able to have a family life. Then we learn that Werner turns out to be an unclean doctor, that is, rumors were spread about him and then many clients left him. In general, we don’t know anything about the future, perhaps it will continue to live as before. I think that Pechorin and Werner are quite similar characters, although there is a difference. He still tries to keep his feelings to himself, and it is better to stay under the mask. It is these people who do not reveal themselves to the end.

The military doctor does not want to achieve something and have a goal, it is easier for him to just watch what is happening. Also, when the time came for the duel, he still approves of Pechorin's decision, but when he comes, he has a sad expression on his face. From this we can conclude that the secondary hero is still nervous. And when such an incident occurred, he did not give in to the main character. I believe that this hero is still with a good heart, but it hurts somehow not decisive.

Composition Characteristics of Werner

One of my favorite works is "A Hero of Our Time". The writer Mikhail Yuryevich Lermontov is the greatest genius of his time, who contributed to the treasury of not only Russian, but also world literature. This novel became central in the writer's work. This wonderful book, which touched me so deeply, has many interesting characters. Now we will talk about one of them, Dr. Werner.

What is special about this character? Immediately, among all the others, he is distinguished by a German surname. However, through the mouth of Pechorin, the author convinces us that he is Russian. Werner has a very unattractive appearance. It contrasts with his fortitude, insight and intelligence. Due to which he is popular with women. Kindness and sympathy, which are manifested in the episode with the dying soldier, are not alien to him.

Among the youth, he receives the nickname Mephistopheles. He secretly rejoices at this nickname. Like Mephistopheles, the character is evil-speaking and has the ability to foresee certain events. Thanks to the painstaking study of people, it is not difficult for him to penetrate the very essence of the nature of the interlocutor. In addition, the similarity with Mephistopheles does not end there. The expression "Mephistopheles' laughter" can also be applied to him. So, in a conversation with Grushnitsky, he taunts him when he changes his soldier's overcoat for a uniform. On the waters, he draws caricatures of wealthy clients whom he treats.

The doctor has a lot in common with the main character of the work - Pechorin. That is why he appears in the novel as his friend. So Werner is not inferior in the art of arguing and caustic phrases to Pechorin, he can endlessly talk on philosophical topics. Werner is the only interesting interlocutor for the protagonist in the novel. Both characters are selfish natures. But as the story progresses, we will begin to notice differences that will eventually even lead to a break in friendship.

Well, completely Werner opens up to the reader after the duel between Pechorin and Grushnitsky. He does not even shake hands with the hero and coldly says goodbye to him, referring to the imminent danger. He did not want to take responsibility for everything that happened.

Werner is a collective image of the Russian intelligentsia of those times. They could discuss any of the proposed topics, wore a mask of decency. However, passive contemplation and philosophizing that did not lead to any results were preferred to decisive actions and activity.

Some interesting essays

  • Escape Mtsyri (goal, why, reasons for escaping) essay
  • Attitude towards the peasants of Dubrovsky and Troekurov

    The great Russian poet and prose writer Alexander Sergeevich Pushkin created in his short life quite a few brilliant works that are read in many countries of the world to this day. Among such creations is the story of the same name "Dubrovsky".

  • Analysis of Gorky's story Childhood Grade 7

    In the work "Childhood" episodes of the difficult childhood of Alexei Peshkov are revealed. It was published under the pseudonym M. Gorky.

  • Analysis of the story of Kuprin Yam essay

    In 1914, A. Kuprin's work "The Pit" appeared, in which he raises the topic of corrupt love. This is the first writer who was not afraid to reveal the lives of women who sell their love.

  • Composition based on the story Kuprin's garnet bracelet

    Kuprin's story "The Garnet Bracelet" is rightfully considered one of the most romantic and sad works of Russian literature. Symbolic images that the author displays through his characters

Dr. Werner is a minor character who serves as a kind of reflection of Pechorin himself. The characters are very similar internally, but completely dissimilar externally. Dr. Werner "A Hero of Our Time" is a representative of the same type of people as the protagonist of the novel: inactive, bored, looking for the meaning of life, but in pursuit of illusions.

Description of Werner's appearance

Dr. Werner is not handsome, rather, on the contrary: “Werner was small, and thin, and weak as a child; one leg was shorter than the other, like Byron's; in comparison with the body, his head seemed huge: he cut his hair with a comb ... ”. He limps in one leg, does not have a strong physique, his face is also unattractive. The only outward merit is the doctor's habit of dressing beautifully, tastefully, neatly: “His small black eyes, always restless, tried to penetrate your thoughts.

Taste and neatness were noticeable in his clothes; his lean, sinewy, and small hands showed off in pale yellow gloves. His coat, tie and waistcoat were always black.”

A sharp mind, charm, manners and inner depth of nature are what attract women to a young man. They feel the subtle nature of a person, which the doctor carefully hides behind sarcasm, indifference, feigned nihilism. Werner loves women, he is an expert and connoisseur in this area. The author describes the nature of this character in a very interesting way: “a poet, and in earnest, is a poet in deed always and often in words, although he has not written two poems in his life ...”. He is a man of high nature, a subtle romantic, a passionate connoisseur of beauty, but all these qualities are hidden behind a mask that is more in line with time and society.

Werner and Pechorin

A former military doctor, Werner treats wealthy aristocrats who have a rest "on the waters". He quickly got along with Pechorin, feeling the kinship of natures, and also quickly realized that true friendship between them was impossible. Pechorin's invitation to Werner to play the role of a second, the disclosure of Grushnitsky's conspiracy against Grigory - all this suggests that the main character can only trust the doctor. During his life, he did not make real friends, he only knows how to take something from any relationship.

People like Pechorin do not know how to create, give, donate. Grigory uses his comrade Werner as a second, as he is very convenient in this situation: honest, truthful, respected, smart, knows how to be silent. In addition, he is well aware that if Grushnitsky dies, Werner will accept this outcome indifferently - he has seen thousands of deaths, one more will not excite his mind. The duel really remained a secret.

The true face of Werner

The events that took place during the duel indicate that Dr. Werner is cowardly and weak-willed, or simply cowardly and vile. The author does not give an unambiguous assessment of what happened. In any case: Werner is not distinguished by high moral principles, he is not capable of actions. A kind of waiting genius: he could become a great man, but he is too prone to laziness, inactivity and dreams. Such a man of genius spends his days vainly but uselessly. The knowledge that Werner possesses could save many lives, but he does not have the willpower and character that could change his nature. In addition, Dr. Werner is caustic and sharp-tongued, he taunts his patients, this mask of irony has become familiar to him. Werner lacks the spirit to be himself, he is subject to public opinion.

Werner is a minor character in the novel A Hero of Our Time, who occupies a special position due to his resemblance to Pechorin. This is a friend of Pechorin, whom they met in the Caucasus during his trip to Pyatigorsk. Werner was a middle-aged military medic. He treated wealthy clients who came to be treated at the waters. Among them were the Ligovskys, with whom Pechorin became close for a while.

By nature, Werner's character is smart, good-natured, and extremely perceptive. Outwardly, he was unsightly, but women liked him for his strength of mind and inner qualities. During Pechorin's duel with Grushnitsky, he acted as a second. He also warned his friend Grigory about Grushnitsky's plot with a certain dragoon captain to leave Pechorin's pistol unloaded.

Until the last lines of the story “Princess Mary”, Pechorin speaks well of the doctor, but when he puts all responsibility for the murder of Grushnitsky on Grigory alone, it becomes clear that spiritual cowardice is inherent in Werner. He also proposes to attribute all the blame to the Circassians. Therefore, the character of the doctor is rather contradictory and cannot be called unambiguously positive.

Werner's life credo is cold decency. He prefers to stay away and contemplate. Further than this, his morality does not extend. In terms of words, he is presented as a worthy rival to Pechorin.

Grigory Pechorin makes acquaintance with Dr. Werner on the waters in Pyatigorsk. The characters are very different, not only in character, but also in appearance, while they have so many common features that Werner is often called the double of the protagonist.

Character appearance

It is difficult to find similarities in their appearance, but there is something in both that makes them stand out from the crowd. In Pechorin, an aristocratic breed is felt: thin hands, light hair, black mustaches and eyebrows, a slightly upturned nose, broad shoulders, sad brown eyes.

Dr. Werner is short, thin, legs of different lengths, a disproportionately large head, his eyes are small and black.

The attitude of Pechorin and Werner to society

The perception of both characters in society is ambiguous. The doctors of the “water society” spread rumors that Dr. Werner was writing caricatures of patients, after which the physician lost his practice.

Gregory is also in constant conflict with the environment, but this is more likely due to his boredom. He is luckier, more attractive and richer than his "double", which becomes the cause of a quarrel with Grushnitsky and his friends. Pechorin and Werner are sharp-tongued, even a little evil ridiculing the shortcomings of others.

Pechorin serves in the army, but is wealthy, so he does not see the need to pursue ranks. Werner is poor, he dreamed of wealth, but did nothing for this. The doctor is bored with treating imaginary illnesses of wealthy patients (just remember what treatment he prescribed for Ligovsky), often laughs at them, but is able to sincerely cry over a dying soldier, which Pechorin once observed.

Heroes' thoughts about women

The opinions of both characters about the opposite sex are similar: Gregory believes that the female mind is extremely paradoxical, in order to convince a lady of anything, you need to forget even the elementary rules of logic. For Werner, the fair sex is like an enchanted forest: at first, monsters surround, but if you persist, a quiet green meadow opens.

Pechorin is more successful in relationships: he is young, smart, attractive and rich. But he himself is not able to love, sincere feelings are inaccessible to him, he is very quickly fed up with even the most beautiful and desirable woman. His attention brings only pain and suffering. Bela, through his fault, is deprived of her father's home, family, and then life. Vera almost loses her honor, and the young Princess Mary suffers such a blow from which she can hardly recover.

Werner, on the other hand, passionately loves women, and often achieves reciprocity, despite external unattractiveness.

The relationship between Pechorin and the doctor

The characters find common ground. Werner takes part in the fate of the main character of the novel, agrees to be his second. During the duel, he calls to expose the conspirators, sincerely caring for his younger friend. But it gives him the opportunity to make decisions on his own, retreating, having heard about his readiness to die in a duel. The doctor's attachment to Pechorin is stronger than the protagonist's attachment to him.

Psychological similarity of heroes

Pechorin is afraid of sincere feelings: passionate love, true friendship, and this is the real reason for his tragedy. Reason prevails over the emotional sphere. He probably realizes that he brings only pain and death to loved ones, destroys their lives, and therefore seeks death either in war or in a duel. He seems to be experimenting on others and on himself, regardless of other people's opinions and other people's feelings.

This is also characteristic of Werner in full measure, but he does not go into open confrontation, while Pechorin goes to the end, infuriating the interlocutor. Not without reason, when the doctor tells the main character that the princess is infatuated with Grushnitsky, both perceive this fact as the plot of a story that can decorate the boredom that reigns in the "water society". At the same time, Pechorin begins to actively act, and Werner continues to observe.

The image of Werner was necessary in order to demonstrate the danger of the individualistic philosophy inherent in romanticism. M. Yu. Lermontov clearly demonstrated the tragedy of the human soul, devoid of faith in anything.